American Idol II

[Laurie_Duke]

I remember Simon saying something on the way the public is voting and that they must respect it...but then on the other hand he did slip in about the looks and the voting for the actual tallent of them....we will see if the public listened, on next weeks voting....why did Josh just keep his head down like that....I think that he was upset not to be in the bottom 2...I think Simons word have finally gotten to him ??

Laurie.

 

[tanyaj77]

Do you guys think it's still the "marine thing" keeping him in?

I really think so because Josh cannot sing anywhere near the way Ruben can.

 

[Raynas mom]

I think that Josh knows he is out of his league...he should have saved Trenyce. He deserved to go home not her.

Oh well I guess we have to hear him another week. :rolleyes:

 

[Spins1344]

Every week I say "oh, I'm gonna vote, I'm gonna vote"...and never do. Well, next week I'm gonna! I don't want Ruben to be in the bottom two again - he does not deserve it at all! He might not be the typical "American Idol" cause he doesn't have the look (meaning he doesn't fit in the stereotype), but what a perfect way to say down with the stereotypical thin to average body types. He is a phenomenal singer. He's perfect the way he is...He is a big teddy bear and a cutie to boot! Everytime I see him on stage, I just wanna give him a big hug! He's definitely got an infectous personality and smile. I was ready to cry when I heard he was in the bottom two, so I could imagine how he felt! Not gonna let that happen next week...so long Joshie boy!!!

Jo-Ann

 

[BrandiLin]

I almost had to pick myself off the floor when they said Ruben was in the bottom two:eek: :eek: . Their calculating machine MUST be wrong!! . I knew it was wrong when goat girl didn't leave a long time before Kim Caldwell. Granted Kim C was an attention who**, but she still sang better than the yodleing goat.:o :o . You know, there was that whole contraversy last year about people using their computers to vote over and over again. Maybe Josh has the more computer savy fans who set their computer to redial every minute for 2 hours. My hubbies friend did that last year for Kelly.

Change subject.... anyone hear Justin last night.....he was jammin. Although he still has the Side-Show Bob hair.

 

[clovick2000]

I can't WAIT for tonight's show..
So- who does everyone REALLY think will win??
I think Ruben SHOULD win- but I think that he won't. But, he'll become a star anyway.
Just a feeling.
Clay had gotten a little boring- but last week, was incredible again. I think the last 2 left standing will be him and Kimberly... or him and Ruben.

I know I"m getting into this early.. just bored at work this afternoon! :D

 

[Spins1344]

It's Ruben all the way for me! I try not to make predictions...I'm just going with who makes me smile and gives me the most chills when he/she comes on stage and performs. I always just wanna give him a big hug! I think no matter what, with these final 4, they will all have some sort of career...but Clay's should only be on broadway...imho..

Jo-Ann

 

[brwneyesk8]

What a laugh!

Don't get me wrong, some of those contestants do have a lot of talent and I admire that. It takes guts to do what they are doing. BUT the ones that can't sing and think they can??? Don't they have family or friends to keep them from humiliating themselves?? Poor kids.

I LOVE to sing. Love it!! Unfortunately Porter covers his ears and Dave says "baby, I love you but don't sing"
:rolleyes:


Oh, Heather...I have internet up again!! I'll e-mail you my new e-mail address tomorrow night!!!!!!!

 

[BrandiLin]

ok, did anyone besides me get a tear in their eye and get goose bumps when Clay sang his first song!!!

Clay made me cry twice during the show. Once with his beautiful first song.....then with laughter at those hip pops in the second song. I was laughing soooooooooo hard I almost pee'd myself

 

[Spins1344]

Yeah, Clay made me cry alright...cry because I was sitting there and listening to him! UGH! I was cringing through "Grease" - the first song wasn't bad (I'll give him that), but I just think he oversings. I know I keep on saying this, but there's a spot on Broadway for him, not as an AI (again, imho, of course!) I thought Kimberley was oversinging a little too in her first song. They just need to relax. I actually thought Josh was decent tonight (hide) :rolleyes: And well, Ruben...he was representing...no words can express my feelings for him! It's gonna be an interesting show tomorrow. Can't wait to hear all of your thoughts!

Jo-Ann