American Idol II

[Spins1344]

Ok guys...give me an update, I missed last night (except for Trenyce's "Proud Mary" rendition) and missed last night too. Was it Josh that went?? I can't see anyone else going, but him, but stranger things have happened....

Jo-Ann
Rocco's Mommy

 

[Spins1344]

OH MY GOD!!! I heard on Fox5 News that RUBEN was in the BOTTOM two...was he voted OFF!?!? Please tell me he wasn't!! I'm in shock that he was even in the bottom two!!!! I can't believe this!!! :confused: I think this show is rigged :mad: I'm not watching anymore if Ruben is off...he's the only reason why I watched...please...I can't wait to hear what happened!!

Jo-Ann
Rocco's Mommy

PS - sorry for the two posts in a row.... :rolleyes:

 

[Chewy's Mom]

I heard it was Trenyce that went home, but yes, I also heard that Ruben was in the bottom 2. How the heck did that happen???

 

[tanyaj77]

Originally posted by Chewy's Mom
I heard it was Trenyce that went home, but yes, I also heard that Ruben was in the bottom 2. How the heck did that happen???

I think that happened because everyone knows Ruben's so awesome that they assume he's safe because "everyone else" will vote for him. I hope this gets everyone's butt in gear so this doesn't happen again.

 

[Tam319]

:eek: :eek: :eek: :eek: :eek:

WHAT!!!!!!!! RUBEN ALMOST GOT THE BOOT!!!!!! You have GOT to be sh*tting me. NOOOOOO WAY!!!!! Did Trenyce go?? Who was the bottom three?? I missed both shows as we are knee deep in home renovations.

Tamara

 

[tanyaj77]

They only had the bottom two this week. Trenyce and Ruben had the least amount of votes but Trenyce got the boot.
When it came down th Ruben and Josh, you could tell that Josh KNEW it should have been him in the bottom 2. When they said Ruben's name, Josh wouldn't even look up.
Oh well....... at least Ruben's still in the contest.

 

[Cayenne's Mom]

I was so shocked to find out that Rueben was in the bottom two. I missed the show but read the show recap on the internet last night. The board I read said that Rueben was shocked and almost cried when he thought he had to go home. I cannot believe that Josh didn't go. Ugh!

 

[clovick2000]

Something must've gone terribly wrong! :eek:
You could tell that Simon was quite angry that Josh wasn't up there. Thank goodness Ruben didn't get the boot, though- he did NOT NOT NOT deserve it!! Neither did Trenyce.. but I would've felt worse if Ruben got kicked off.

 

[DaleLuke]

OH MY GOD! Josh wasn't even in the bottom two...WHAT! He sang the worse songs and badly at that. Do you guys think it's still the "marine thing" keeping him in? Clay was wonderful..I would buy his cd in a minute!! Reuben does not deserve to be in the bottom 2. Kim was also super-I love her personality...I never vote but boy, did I learn my lesson...next week I'll vote, vote,vote!!!

 

[Muttluvr]

My Rueben theory

So I think that the reason Reuben was in the bottom two is because all of the teeny-boppers who were voting for Carmen and blond Kim (or another way of saying it... people who were voting for "looks" instead of voice) have moved their votes to Clay or Josh, the "next best thing".

Next week I'm going to vote, vote, vote for Reuben and Kimberly!