American Idol II

[SammynDqtz]

I thought the bottom 3 should have been Josh, Carmen, and Rickey(or Kim Caldwell), with Josh being the one getting the boot.

 

[Muttluvr]

Yeah, I'm surprised Rickey wasn't in the bottom three either. I used to like him, but his high-pitched sound is starting to get to me.

I used to like it when he'd say "Hercules, Hercules!" But I guess someone told him is sounded stupid so he stopped

 

[SammynDqtz]

So, what did everyone think of tonights show? I thought the worst ones were Carmen, and Kim Caldwell. They did the worst I've ever seen! If I had my say the bottom 3 would be: Kim Caldwell, Carmen, and Josh. I don't like any of them. Josh is ok when it comes to country, but I'm not really into that, so I won't miss him. When they did disco night I'm sure he wasn't "a little bit sick'', he just could not do it, it was HORRIBLE! I wasn't there to watch that night, but I heard all about it, and then got to see a clip of it. I think he gets some of his votes just because of what he does, not his singing talent. But anyway those are my bottom 3 picks. And as ALWAYS, Rueben is the BEST!!!!!!! He does it perfect every time!!!
GO RUEBEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D

 

[Tam319]

Yeah, Josh was bad tonight. He always screws his face up and looks like he's passing a stone when he's singing. It drives me nuts! Carmen was bah-bah-bad tonight. I think the top three will be 1) Rueben 2) Clay 3) Kimberly Locke or Trenyce. The bottom three this week should be 1) Carmen 2) Blonde Kimberly 3) Josh. I think Hercules-Hercules will be right in the middle between safety and getting the boot.

It is sooooo obvious that everyone (judges, crowd, people watching) think Roooooooo-ben will win...its kind of like they are going thru the motions til the competition is over.

What do you guys think?

Tam

P.S. I really liked tonight's topic...MUCH better than disco or country.

 

[Chewy's Mom]

Tam, you crack me up! Passing a stone...

Ruben is SO going to win this thing! It is pretty obvious to the whole world.

Bottom 3 should be Kimberly Caldwell (blonde), Carmen, and...hmmmm... I don't care. As long as one of those 2 goes home, that's all I care about.

 

[Muttluvr]

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOHHHHHHHHHHHHHH I missed it!!

Why oh WHY did I sign up for agility on Tuesday nights? This means I'll miss alllllll remaining episodes *SOB*

 

[Chewy's Mom]

You had better set your VCR to record it from now on, missy!

 

[buddy's_mom_29]

I agree the bottom 3 should be Carmen, blonde Kimberly, and Joshua. Poor Carmen does stink, and I've never liked Kimberly. And I don't believe Joshua was sick on disco night either, I totally think they were making excuses for him!! I don't like him either, and Tam you are right on the money with the awful faces he makes :rolleyes: Go Roooooooooben!!!!

 

[Cayenne's Mom]

I really thought everyone but Carmen was much improved. I thought Kimberly Caldwell looked so pretty. Finally she looked sophisticated and not trashy. Too bad she cannot sing...LOL I agree that the bottom three should include Kimberly and Carmen but I was not that impressed with either Tyrence or Kimberly Locke. I thought Josh did alright because he choose a song he has probably sang a zillion times at karaoke. Anyway we shall see tonight...I hope I get home in time from puppy class and agility...:D

 

[Raynas mom]

Carmen was so bad that we had to turn down the volume!!
Josh needs to buy a clue because this is not Country Idol !!
Kimberly C- can only do raspy songs...I think she has just one tone!!
Tyrence over does it!!
Clay was wearing lip stick...and I hate the eye batting thing he does.

Rueben is a star he can sing anything and he does it with style!
Kimberly Locke brings it every week I think she gets better and better...her style and her singing!

Rickey is okay...I agree he is in the middle some place.