Well to be honest with you, I got a crate from Wal-Mart. It was the smallest one. I only crated her for the first 3 weeks I had her. I havent crated her in like 4 weeks. She has been doing really good. I let her have the roam of the house. I make sure that I unplug everything before I leave for work. I put up her food and water bowl and leave alot of chew toys around. I have her on a feeding schedule. She eats in the morning after she goes outside to potty (like around 6am). After she eats I take her food and water bowl away from her. I take her out before I leave for work (7:45am) and then she poops and pees. When I get home, I take her out (5:30pm) and she does her job and the she eats again. She has been getting better. She knows to poop and pee (if she has to) by the front door. I got her one of those cow bells from PetsMart on put it on the door. Everytime we go out (doesn't matter for a walk, play, or potty) I ring the bell. She knows now to ring the bell when I am at home. I have noticed that since I have not crated her during the day she is alot calmer and is not a spaz. When I used to crate her she was like out of control. If you have patience for the the accidents in your home, I have been having much luck with her not in the crate. Of course when I leave I close all the doors, bedroom, closets, and bathrooms. She mostly stays down stairs. Madalynn has been really good with the non-crating. She also has been extremly good with not cheewing the couch, and other stuf. (got the non-chew spray. really helps). When you get your precious baby, I will more than willing to talk if you have questions. Cause it is hard when I first got her to find another boxer owner. Hope to talk to you soon!