I would avoid the crate and go with the room option then, so the crate doesn't get associated with punishement.
What I actually do is close all the bedroom doors at the end of the hall and make the dog sit and stay at that end of the hall, which is basically now a closed room. I am in the living room at the other end of the hall monitoring that she actually stays there (they always try to slink back to the living room
) until the 10 minutes are up. When the 10 minutes are up I call her from the living room to come to me and then life goes on.
What I actually do is close all the bedroom doors at the end of the hall and make the dog sit and stay at that end of the hall, which is basically now a closed room. I am in the living room at the other end of the hall monitoring that she actually stays there (they always try to slink back to the living room
...We have an extra, unused bedroom that we use as his 'time-out' room. We just have to mention it and Tank usually starts behaving. My husband has decided now that he's going to teach him "3, 2, 1..." and if he doesn't stop by then he'll go to his room. (We'll see how that goes!