Innova or Chicken Soup

[TaliDad]

Which is better overall kibble? I am looking for a kibble that she will eat right up. She was on Nutro and I she was okay on that. But I want her to have something that she really looks forward to.

I recently changed to Blue Buffalo, but she doesn't seem to like it.

Any ideas?

 

[gmacleod]

Oooh - hard choice. IMO you've picked two of the best kibbles around there, and it's not that easy to choose between them.

I would probably lean very slightly toward the Innova as being the better. But not by much Really, either one of them would be a great choice.

How about asking for a couple of sample bags and seeing which one your pup prefers? Sometimes that's hard to predict, and sadly (just like human kids) what they prefer is not governed solely by quality LOL

 

[MeganMK]

We just bought two bags of Chicken Soup for puppies yesterday. Lucky hasn't tested it out yet, but I hope he loves it!

 

[Jamielyn]

I use Chicken soup for my two. They love it.

 

[sonomagirl]

Read the ingredients - Innova sounds good enough for me to eat!

 

[Erica&Riley]

I think you'll find that you will pay a lot more for Innova. There is about a $10 price difference near me. I'm not sure if this is a consideration for you...

Good luck!

 

[fieldfamily]

We had our Legend on Eagle Pack Holistic and he lost intrest in it at about 6 months and we switched to Chicken Soup and he loves this food. He also seems to do better on it as well. His coat is beautiful and we also noticed a drastic change in his stool for the better, he goes alot less and alot smaller and not near as odorus. I am hoping he likes this food for along time.

 

[TaliDad]

Anyone tried the Nutro holistic? Is it any good?

 

[Morgan3]

Scooter eats Nutro Ultra (holistic), likes it well enough and convenient and easy to get (Petsmart). We also have tried Blue Buffalo (wouldn't eat it) and Chicken Soup. Ate the chicken soup, but his stools were always very soft and tons of it!
Thinking of switching to Canidae...

 

[msjosi]

Josi has been on Innova for over three years now and I am so thankful that my friend introduced me to this brand of food. After going through probably 8-10 different brand foods (moderate to high quality) throughout her life, Innova is the first one that agreed with her stomach. It also has done wonders for her shiny coat and she gives it a PAWS UP for taste!