Luckily, Allie came pretty well trained! Dieter needs some work, and I often wonder about his past. He's been with three other owners before coming into my home (and he's only 1.5 years old). He has a questionable knobby scar on the top of his head and cowers if you tell him "no" then go near him. Breaks my heart wondering if he's ever been hit before.
Aww this is the doggie I was thinking about!
Three other owners?? Wow so either the dog has "issues" or just bad luck or incompatibility of some kind, no matter.
It looks like your doing exactly the same thing, I did (and wound up with issues 18 months down the road) and everybody else does when they get a new dog..perfunctory, introduction to the resident dog, here's the food here's the water theres you bed a couch if you want...make yourself at home!
Most people do that I did, sometimes you get lucky (no issues) sometimes you don't ( Big freaking issues!)
Your guy sitting away kinda shows no real bond, he's sorta like Oh well this is a nice place to be till it's time to move on again. :(
I want this guy to succeed, he's got no issue's wit your girl and that's great makes life easier but it's not enough. He needs to know that everything in his life comes from you!
I going to suggest that you register on the German Shepherd Board and search for "Two Week Shutdown." You can read about it without registering but if you register you can ask questions from people who have been here and done that.
You can read about it and see what you think, it's my policy going forward! I did'nt do it and had big time "issues" with my BullMastiff and GSD (after he had been in the home for 18 months without a problem!!!)
I really,really want to see this guy have a forever home and you can do more than depend on lucy to see that it happens for him!
Oh and I have given some thought to the counter surfing thing. Again I never had it as an issue but my guys had all the basics down and it was just never an issue. But while training I did notice that both my Boxer and Boxer mix both detested the down command!
See where I'm going with this? If you catch him going at the counter...the command is "down" and stay then release and treat.
You can bait the counter with a hotdog later to proof him and he would get a different treat for not counter surfing.
But the bonding issue needs to be addressed first! If you do the two week or one week shutdown there is no training or walks involved during this time!
Good luck to you all!