Like Cubby I don't regard it as "cosmetic" at all. Both Diva and Monty had their dew claws removed by the breeder, but I have a friend who has a Weimaraner (4 years old) and this Wei doesn't have her dew claws removed. She is forever catching them, one in particular and now this one is really really loose and will require surgery to remove. My understanding is that removing a dew claw on a fully grown adult dog is fairy major surgery, so I think you've done the absolute best thing for the dog.
