American Idol II

[DaleLuke]

Clay and Goatie have been VERY hoochi-koochi the last few weeks- what the age difference anyway? I know she's just 17 or 18 because she's still in high school. I CAN"T believe we have to live thru another goat-filled week (3 days next week!). Do we have boxer belly-botton lint in our ears and the rest of America is hearing something different?? I'm liking Kim Locke more and more each week -she has class!!!

 

[neilsmom2000]

How on earth did Kimberly get voted off before Goat Girl? Carmen was TERRIBLE! I was totally shocked by the results of the vote.

Please PLEASE Americans voting on American Idol, put Goat Girl out to pasture next week! :p I can't bear another week of her!

 

[K & J]

two quick thoughts........
1) I just can't believe Carmen didn't get it this week. I nearly had a stroke. It's absurd. Although if it wasn't her, I can't say I'm heartbroken to see AI Barbie go.
2) Does anyone else feel like this is all getting to be a bit ....redundant? I mean, if Ruben doesn't win this thing, it will be a precursor to the apocalypse. Taps will run blood... fire and brimstone... etc. I mean, seriously. We could almost dispense with the rest of the shows, if it weren't so damned entertaining to watch the non-Ruben contestants squirm.

happy viewing next week! 3 nights to look forward to!

:p Karen

 

[Spins1344]

Originally posted by DaleLuke
Joanne, Why don't you like Clay? He's my second favorite after Reubin...He's not much to look at but his voice is incredible!

To answer your question...Clay is just too theatrical for me. He has a good voice, but he should be on broadway...not on American Idol. I was hoping that both Kim C and Carmen would get booted...but atleast I hope we can take comfort in knowing that Carmen will get the boot next week - let's hope anyway! So, we're at 6 now...you guys are so right about Josh's painful faces! But before he goes, Carmen must! Clay will be all lonesome when Carmen goes...they have been a little touchy feely. I think the final two will be Kimberley Locke and 205 ROOOOBEN STUDDARD! Can ya tell who my pick is to win!!

Jo-Ann

 

[HD_Cruisin8]

I don't know much to say, just that I'm as big of fan as a lot of people are of Am.Id. I think Ruuuuuuuuuben's gonna win..he rox!! I like Clay, but he doesn't change his voice to fit a song, doesn't matter what kind of song it is he sounds the same..like yall said too theatrical. He sounds like he could almost be an opera singer!! .. I like Josh, I think if he get kicked off, someone in Nashville will get him and sign him..he'd be a helluva good country singer, I think he sounds better than Garth Brooks(b/c I think his voice is reminiscent of garth's) Still think ROOOOO will win it. I've noticed...a female one the 1st am. idol, so a male will win it this time.. They voted a guy off the week b4 this past week then this past weds. they voted a guy off.. So this week it will probably be a girl(goat girl).. Oh that's a question..do yall call her that b/c of the way she sings, if so I think it sounds weird too! I didn't like Kim C. I really don't care for Carmen either.. This week I think the bottom 3 will be Carmen, Kim L., and Trenyce..well ttyl.
Paige

 

[Muttluvr]

Originally posted by K & J
I can't say I'm heartbroken to see AI Barbie go.

Teehee, the first time I read this I mentally substituted AI=Artificial Intelligence instead of AI=American Idol.

I guess either could fit with her!

(or am I being too mean? )

 

[Tam319]

Originally posted by Muttluvr
Teehee, the first time I read this I mentally substituted AI=Artificial Intelligence instead of AI=American Idol.

I guess either could fit with her!

(or am I being too mean? )

Well I thought it was Artificial Insemination so don't feel bad!

Tam

 

[kelseighgirl]

and once again.....

GO RUEBEN appicon

the contest belongs to 205!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[neilsmom2000]

Oh no! I want Goatgirl to go, but Josh stunk so bad tonight, I think he's going to be the next to go. I thought Randy's comments about Carmen were dead on!
Now excuse me, but I think I have to go colour my hair with Herbal Essences hair dye---no wait, that's just the victim of corporate-shameless-product-plugging-during-a-useless-segment brainwashing talking!:rolleyes:

--Barb

 

[SammynDqtz]

Simon was right on tonight when he said: Josh sounded like he sang though his nose! and Carmen won't win this thing, and Clay belongs on broadway, everything was right on. I hope Josh or Carmen goes tomorrow. Hope Rueben wins! :D