I have to agree with the breeder on this one. We bought a pet quality Boxer from champion lines. We paid almost a thousand dollars and had no qualms about signing the agreement.
We also have a rescue female that we also signed a contract to have spayed.
I have no desire to breed, nor do I have the money, time or the experience. I strongly disagree with people who buy from champion lines and then breed with another neighborhood Boxer because they think that he is handsome or has a great personality. There is much more involved in breeding than that. I am not saying that this is everyone's intention. But we met a lot of BYB's in our search. They think that they have good intentions and in their mind they do but they are not bettering the breed and they are not responsible breeders. We watched people come in to see a litter while we were seeing the litter. The people picked out a pup, paid for it and left. They were never asked their intentions for the pup, they were not asked about vet care, environment, home life etc.. To me, this is irresponsible breeding.
If someone intends to start breeding, they need to do their homework, line up the money for testing, be prepared to wait two years to breed their dam and find a breeder that is willing to mentor you with one of their pups. If you are not willing to do this then you need to sign a spay/neuter contract.
I do not understand why people are so unwilling to sign. I have worked in shelters and with rescues. The numbers of dogs that are put down are staggering. You cannot save them all and you cannot place them all. It is a sad fact. The best you can do is educate the public on the importance of spaying/neutering their dogs and work your butt off to place the ones in the shelter into responsible caring homes.
I am off my soapbox now.