Sherri---I dont have any good suggestions for plush toys seeing as Titan rips heads, ears, arms, legs etc. off within 24 hrs usually. I have found that toys with voice boxes are quickest to go though and squeekers are next. So I try to eliminate those for sure. The only toys he has that still have all their body parts are these AKC mallard, squirrel and rabbit he has from PetSmart- for some reason he doesn't try to rip them up. I try to buy plush toys with ropes or balls attached to them to try to distract him a bit, just a thought. I've bought the "indestructible" toys before too and they dont seem to make a difference.