True Aggression in a Boxer?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Saracirce

Boxer Pal
By 'true aggression', I mean, it's not fear, leash reactiveness or same-sex aggression. I'm honestly not sure how to proceed with Clementine's training when it comes to meeting other dogs other then to basically give up on her and say she's just plain aggressive.

Clemmy came to live with me when she was just turning 2 years old. The first couple months were rocky while she settled in and we were getting used to her presence. When she had finally settled in, she started become reactive towards other dogs and it escalated rather quickly. I'm talking intense staring, barking with hackles up and pulling so hard on the leash that she's standing on her back paws. She even exacerbated an injury I had from a fall (which wasn't her fault) and caused a pulled muscle/tendon in my shoulder.

The very first thing I tried with her is treating it as if she's afraid of the other dogs. I would have her sit with her back to the dog(s) a few feet off the bike trail we walk on and give her treats as the dog came closer. However, she would zone in on the dog no matter how far we went and even her favorite treats weren't nearly as rewarding as reacting to the other dog. The treats even seemed to make her worse. I tried toys next since she's also got a decent toy drive but that just upped her excitement levels and, again, reacting to the other dog is far better then her favorite toys.

Most recently, I've tried treating it as if the leash was making her frustrated and that she's just so excited to see other dogs that she can't contain herself. I ask people if I can 'borrow' them and their dog and then work with Clemmy. We walk like we normally would towards the dog until she pulls or reacts. I promptly say 'Let's go!' in a cheery voice, spin around and walk the other way. Once she calms down, we turn back around and walk towards the dog again. This has resulted in that, for the most part, the barking and pulling has gone away. However, the hackles and intense stares are still there.

The other thing is that, when she does behave enough and I trust the other dog enough that she's allowed to meet it, the initial butt sniffing goes well. After the sniffing, however, she likes to get in the other dog's face and becomes tense and frozen, followed by her 'snapping'. Even if I try to guide her away before that stage, she still 'snaps'. And I do mean guide. I NEVER pull on the leash. I simply say 'Let's go' and take a step in the direction we want to go. Meetings are always with a loose leash and with me being as calm as I can be. (I have some of my own issues which don't always allow me to be calm and which can't always be predicted.) Also, when she realizes she's not being allowed to meet the dog, it's instantly back to her old ways of barking and pulling.

This is with dogs of every shape and size that we can find. There's even one BC we've met frequently. Today we saw him and she zoned in like usual. The BC immediately slowed down so that he fell behind his owner, pointed his nose to the ground, the whites of his eyes showing and lowered his tail from his normal carriage. The owner commented that he was 'being shy' but, really, he was saying she was being aggressive and he didn't want to meet her. Even when he does meet her, he's a polite little angel and, when she 'snaps', he promptly moves away. The dog that Clemmy is the absolute worst with is a miniature, off-white male poodle. The two seem to feed off each other in a bad way and his owner has commented that she's the only dog he acts aggressively with.

All this being said, Clemmy does have a bit of a rocky past. She was born to a bad BYB where she was chained up for the first four months and had to fight her parents for food. She does have fear issues (though she practices flight instead of fight) and she used to have a 'doggy friend'. He was a big chow that she knew from four months to almost two years, though I never got to see them interact in person. We do have another dog (chi-dachshund mix) who IS fear aggressive and she's also a senior. Clemmy isn't allowed to play with the little one and we've always reinforced in Clemmy to back off whenever she's told to by her. Basically, the little dog is 'off limits' to Clementine because she just wants absolutely nothing to do with another dog. Her owners also claim that Clementine ONLY shows dog aggression with me and not with them but it's not like that walk her all that often either. And, lastly, there's no where for us to go where we can safely allow dogs off leash. My town is not dog friendly and there isn't even a pet store here, let alone a dog park. Private fencing is also a rare commodity and fencing over 4 or 5 feet is basically unheard of. While I trust Clemmy off leash when it's just us, I don't trust her off leash around other dogs.

</endwalloftext>
 

johann

Boxer Insane
First, stop letting her greet dogs. It is setting her up to fail every time, and the behavior becomes more ingrained. To me (not a trainer), it doesn't sound like true aggression because she is able to calmly sniff and greet for a moment. Has she ever been off leash and played with other dogs? How was she then? It really sounds like you have the right idea and methods, but may be moving too fast for her.

Where in Maine are you? I am pretty familiar with trainers in the southern, coastal, and central Maine areas and can get you a referral for someone who is good with behavioral issues (there aren't any true behaviorists in the state, but quite a few very experienced trainers that could help you a lot). There are also some really bad trainers too, so be wary.

As for off leash time, I wouldn't risk it at this point. Does the town have a baseball field or anything like that? We used to let Johann run around on the little league field to get exercise. If you want to tire her out more, you can try a long lead (30ft) so she can run and play....but still be under your control.

Lastly, if you are anywhere near the Saco/Portland area, I'd be happy to meet up for a walk sometime. Johann is a great calm dog (on walks, not in off leash settings because he has a bad back and will react/fight) and maybe we can work on some of her reactivity?

A great book for this is Control Unleashed. I actually took a class based on the book and it completely changed how I view Johann's behavior and how we manage it.
 

Saracirce

Boxer Pal
I'm in the Presque Isle/Caribou area (central Aroostook) so nowhere near you, unfortunately.

The only time she's met a dog off leash around me is when we were introducing her to Lolita (our little dog). It happened in our house (I know, not how I would've chosen to introduce them either) and she was pretty well behaved but we had one of her owners with us. There was a lot of standing over Loli and Loli piddled on the floor even though she's house broken. Clemmy did try to play with her but that had to be nipped in the bud because the little one's got arthritis and just generally dislikes dogs. (Now the two just act like the other one doesn't exist most of the time, which is kinda perfect) Other then that, no other dogs. There is this dog I petsit that I would love to introduce her to but he can't be trusted off leash and there's no suitable neutral zones to go to.

Something I tend to forget is that, when Clemmy was coming over for visits before she came to live with me and for a bit after she lived with me, she acted like she wasn't used to the leash. She would bite it and pull somewhat sporadically. I don't think they used the leash very often with her and the few times I have seen her on leash with them, they hold it very tight and walk her as if she's unpredictable and needs to be kept close. (At least, that's what I think whenever I see people walking their dogs like that.)

No baseball field or anything that we can use. The only ones are owned by the High School. For off leash time, she has our huge backyard (we live on a dead end street and she has a great re-call) and sometimes this park where I have a mostly unobstructed view for about 50 feet all around us. I always take her on days and at times where there are practically no dogs being walked.
 

johann

Boxer Insane
I'll ask my trainer friends if anyone knows someone up in that area.
be reactive/aggressive. Based on how quickly she seems to settle once the dog is out of sight. Truly aggressive dogs tend to be still and quiet....not making a huge fuss . If you do a search, there should be great threads on here about how to handle leash aggression.

I'd definitely recommend the book control unleashed now, especially the section on the "look at that" game. Made a huge, huge difference in Johann's leash reactivity.

Funny side note- I grew up in Presque Isle. :)
 

chrystel

Boxer Insane
I don't know if this will help.. but Oxford is EXACTLY like your Clementine.

He has no bad past. We got him at 9 weeks old ;) He was like that from day 1. what a pleasure little puppy, bullying everyone.. except our other boxer. He respect Snatch and adoooores him! Snatch decides when to play, when play is over, when to eat.. etc...

We have seen a behaviorist. She did a very interesting test. She told me to get out of the room and come back loose leash... She had placed a fake stuffed toy shaped as a dog in the middle of the room and told to come calmly towards it.
Reaction: Oxford spotted the dog, hair spiked.. and because of course I was not nervous at all, he hid behind my legs, lip licking, not wanting to approach the stuff toy! I stopped by the toy and he was VERY nervous and afraid.

Now same test with a real dog? He reacted like your girl. The behaviorist explained to me that because I get nervous (of course, this is human), Oxford feeds off me, feels like i'm nervous too, and wants to control the "problem".

For a matter of fact, Oxford is very reactive to movement. a still dog he doesn't react.. a running dog? oh my!

We worked for 8 weeks with the behaviorist. She has given me tool. She had 1 recommendation: DO NOT SET HIM UP FOR FAILURE.
Know your baby's trigger (dog, cat, whatever) and the distance at which he feels safe. I know now how much distance I can pass a dog WITHOUT him reacting.

See in your video? for example, when she sees the dog, her ears perked up. this is a good sign for you to distance yourself. Do not try too hard because you will create a pattern, a habit, she will teach herself to react. Instead of praising her after she has reacted, cross the road to distance yourself from the dog and praise her as she walk calmly.

You can get in a habit "see the dog? good clementine, very good!" as she is CALM.
Never praise her after she reacts. Your are stressed, she is stressed ;)

Anyway. this is what I deal with. Oxford is 6, 68lbs of muscle, black (people get so scared because of his colour.. it's silly. he adores people and is so goofy!) BUT I will never trust him with meeting a strange dog. We never get close.

He does go to daycare. I am not there. I drop him, no emotion. He does awesome there and plays well ;)
He has doggy friends he loves. I will never understand ;)

Good luck. I know it is always a work in progress.

Yesterday again, I got charged by 2 small dogs off leash! (shitzu and poodle). very aggressive, they were zig zagging between our legs! To top it off, the owner called me a b@#@! and told me I had a vicious dog that needed to be taken cared of! (!!!!!!!) ... I reported her to the apartment complex and next time I will call the police on her... some people are just idiots. Her dogs were off leash, crossed the road, almost got hit by a car.. and she had the nerve to call my dog vicious... ugh...

Good luck! :)
 

Saracirce

Boxer Pal
The 'Let's Go!' command has gone a long way towards getting her to calm down faster and move on. She used to stubbornly refuse to walk on at all until the other dog was too far away and she used to not calm down at all during the entire walk after seeing a dog. Her walks are about 30 minutes each. She also used to get progressively worse with each dog she'd see, obviously since she wasn't calming down between them. Walking when there's less dogs out and the 'Let's Go!' command have helped a ton.

I'll look into the book and look at other threads on here.

Clemmy is actually less reactive towards a dog that reacts to her then she is to a neutral or friendly dog. If the other dog reacts first, she just kinda stands there dumbfounded and watching them. First time she did that, a beagle had gotten loose and came charging up to us. Prime opportunity for a dog fight, right? I was all prepared to have to break them up but Clemmy just stood there watching and the dog stopped within a foot of us and started sniffing the ground like it was unsure what to do now. And we just stood there like that while the owner came to get the beagle.

The reason I didn't move to the side in the video is because there are trees and bushes directly to my left (Clemmy and the other dog are to my right). Our only option for an alternative route would've been to go up to a very busy street with no sidewalks or go down that street we crossed and past a noisy construction site with a dog who has such a high fear of loud noises she'll try to slip her collar. I chose the lesser of two evils. Nor does it seem to matter how far away the dog is. Later on in that very same walk, I spotted a loose dog about 20 to 30 feet ahead of us and I stopped her to just wait for the owners to get it. She started barking and pulling as soon as she saw it. (Then again, we had a toddler behind us on a really loud tricycle and who was yelling at us so she was already anxious. The parents didn't feel the need to tell the toddler off until they saw her acting aggressively and I couldn't tell them to stop their kid without yelling since they were so far behind him and that would've made Clemmy worse.) I was praising Clemmy for a few seconds of calm and for looking forward instead of back as well as rewarding her with loosening the leash a bit, by the way.

I have to admit, I'm a little worried about the 'look at that' game. We often will gasp and whisper to Clemmy 'what's that?' or 'who's that?' and it sends her running straight for the window, ready to go on alert. Not the state of mind she needs to be in when seeing another dog, you know?
 
Last edited:

TwoDogs

Boxer Insane
I have to admit, I'm a little worried about the 'look at that' game. We often will gasp and whisper to Clemmy 'what's that?' or 'who's that?' and it sends her running straight for the window, ready to go on alert. Not the state of mind she needs to be in when seeing another dog, you know?

Don't worry. That's not how you'll be playing "Look at That". If done according to Leslie's instructions, LAT is a calm exercise. You really start LAT training with an inanimate object, then move on to other things that don't get the dog excited. I did a huge amount of pulling an object from behind my back in the early stages before I progressed to using a 30 foot long line to pull an object into view from behind a corner, to a boring person stepping from behind that corner, to a person stepping from behind the corner jingling a leash and collar. My dog was really good at the game before I added a dog into that scenario.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top