Land of Granola

Status
Not open for further replies.

Austin's Mom

Boxer Insane
I think we're just so used to seeing them with their nubbies that long tails don't look right to some of us. It's like seeing a dog that normally has a long tail with a nubbie. I personally love the nubbie!
 

karonadams

Boxer Booster
Tae is SO cute! I love the way her ail curles up. the first thing i thought of was like a whippet tail for a miute! this is the first tailed boxer i have seen. like i said, it all SHOULD come back to personal prefernce as well as traditional practice. I like my little nubbies, myself. i have a floppy and a crop, niether was really a choice, jsut the way it happened. but i think, given a choice, i would chose cropped. but then i am very much a traditionalist, so i would prefer the traditional look. origianlly the ears and the tails were done to reduce injusries in fights with buls and bears, IIRC

karon
 

Tucker's Mom

Super Boxer
You know how Boxers get so excited that they can't wag their nubs fast enough, so they wag their entire hiney? If they have tails, do they still do that?

And I have a similar reason for loving the floppy ears! When tucker shakes, it starts at his butt, rolls up his body, and then hits his cheeks, lips, and ears. It's like a tuning fork, and it's just so cute. Those lips and ears shake longer than the rest of him, and they make that adorable flopping noise. (Plus, I think the floppy years make their faces look softer and more snuggly)
 

craZ4HERKIE

Boxer Insane
I was going to tell ya'll to ask Becky about Tae, because she's gorgeous with her tail, and I've never read any stories where Becky has said anything about tail injuries. But I see she's already posted. IMO I think it should come down to your personal preference. Herkie has his natural ears and a nubbie, my ex-BF wanted to get his ears cropped, but I just couldn't bear to do it. Especially since Herkie's best friend as a pup was a Dobie pup the same age named Keano, and his owner was having a FIT with his ears! No way was I going to put Herkie through that after I saw Keano, although he did look soooo cute with his little bandages on!
 

owen's mum

Boxer Booster
Please don't Throw Things.

I'm going to be the unpopular one here and say that I mostly agree with the ban. I hear about all these ear cropping stories and taping puppy ears just to get a certain look. I think it is cruel and selfish. I am glad that Owen came with a nubbin, but if he had a tail, he would have kept it.

***Just my humble opinion.***

BTW-I saw a link-I think it was here- about a man in Europe crossing boxers and Pembroke Welsh Corgies (sp?) to create a naturally nubbed boxer. Now I think that is the best of both worlds :D !
 

Ciscobxr

Boxer Insane
owen's mum said:
BTW-I saw a link-I think it was here- about a man in Europe crossing boxers and Pembroke Welsh Corgies (sp?) to create a naturally nubbed boxer. Now I think that is the best of both worlds :D !

That would not be a "naturally nubbed boxer", it would be a mutt. All he is doing is adding to the overpopulation, and the next dogs that will end up in kill shelters.
 

Mama_Zookeeper

Boxer Insane
Boxer nubbies are part of their appeal, at least for me.
I do like how Miss Tae looks with her tail curled upwards though.

Dora
 

BONGO

Banned
Docking

When docked at the appropriate age, the nerves in the tail are not developed and cause the pup no pain and minimal bleeding. Growing up on a farm, we (my father and I) have docked thousands of piggy tails and dozens of doggie tails (Rotties). Nobody has mentioned the AKC standard!! Our girl is docked, natural (adopted that way), but who cares? We love our kiddos no matter what! Circumcising our human baby boys causes some pain but we do it.
 

gmacleod

Elusive Moderator
Staff member
Ciscobxr said:
That would not be a "naturally nubbed boxer", it would be a mutt. All he is doing is adding to the overpopulation, and the next dogs that will end up in kill shelters.
Umm. I think not. That would be Dr Bruce Cattanach and his bobtail boxer program - which are, incidentally, accepted from the 5th (I think) generation cross as purebred boxers around the world. There are bobtails in several countries, including, I believe, the US ;)

Dr Cattanach has been a boxer breeder since the 1940s. He is one of the world's leading canine geneticists, boxer judge, founder of UK health screening programs... and quite a few other things besides. I'd suggest you do a little research on Dr Cattanach and his Bobtails before slandering them. Not everyone's cup of tea, for sure, but by no means is this the production of mutts that will end up in shelters either. On the contrary, they are being successfully shown in several countries - and have even qualified for Crufts in some cases. You can read a little about the bobtails at http://www.steynmere.com./BOBTAILS.html

For obvious reasons, there are significant breeding programs underway in some countries that have banned docking. Far from ending up in shelters, in some cases there simply are not enough bobtail boxers to satisfy demand...

PS: Bongo - this is an international site, not a US one. Some countries have their own standard, but it's worth noting that the one most widely in use around the world (the FCI) calls for a natural tail ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top