Update
Well, the verdict is in and my guys have given Fromm two very enthusiastic "paws up." I'm currently feeding their Four Star Nutritionals Chicken a la Veg formula and they go bonkers when it's meal time! In all fairness, they usually go a little crazy at meal times, but they never reacted to Orijen or TOTW like they do with Fromm. I actually had to get after them when I was dumping the food from the bag into the large dog food bin I have in my kitchen because they were both being possessive of the kibble and a mini growling/snapping match broke out. We had a few days of loose stools while I was transitioning, but I think that had more to do with the little stinkers getting into a swamp and drinking the stagnant and potentially bacteria infested water during a recent, off-leash walk.
We had issues with really loose stools when I tried them on Orijen and their stools improved considerably on TOTW, but still tended to be rather soft and difficult to clean up. Their stools are now well formed, firm, and super easy to dispose of. And I sleep better at night knowing that their food is 100% ethoxyquin free. It's a win-win for everybody