Hopefully the person who suggested sardines to me reads this (liamsmom). So I went to the store today and bought Jade some sardines because it was so kindly suggested to me. When I got home I mixed up Jade's kibble and sardines (stinky) and she smelled them and was sitting waiting for her food so she had to do a down to earn her bowl. She ate that up in a split second and then we went out for our after dinner poo\potty time and I was rewarded with very very excited boxer burns for ten minutes or so. Boy those sardines make her a happy happy pup. I think that there will always be sardines in our cabinets now!!!!!